The U.S. Supreme Court declined Monday to hear the case between Kentridge High School, located in Kent, Wash., and two former students who fought to form a Bible study group that excluded non-Christians from becoming voting members.
“Obviously we were disappointed,” said Tim Chandler, legal counsel for the former students. “We were hoping the Supreme Court would resolve it.”
The school in 2003 denied a charter for the group, called Truth, saying its membership requirements discriminated against students who refused to sign a statement accepting Jesus as their personal savior. Truth founders argued that the school denied their First Amendment rights and violated the Equal Access Act by preventing them from forming a group according to their religious beliefs.
Truth’s founders filed their case with one major question in mind: Can a school district refuse to charter student organizations that restrict membership based on religion?
District and appellate courts responded with a resounding “yes.”
Usually when the Supreme Court refuses to hear a case, that means it’s over, but a legal loophole means this six-year battle might stick around.
Lawyers for the two former students say they might refile the case — starting over in U.S. District Court — with a different legal question: Did Kentridge High School already allow something similar?
Attorneys are researching whether some boys’ and girls’ groups — what Lind calls “vestiges of an older age” — at the school might have once limited their membership based on gender, putting them in a similar legal situation as Truth.

The Rutherford Institute is taking the case of a valedictorian’s graduation speech to the U.S. Supreme Court.
A law firm that defends and promotes Christian heritage and moral values has filed suit on a behalf of a Sudanese Christian who recently was barred from handing out Christian literature in the streets of Dearborn, Mich.
A Christian pastor and staunch opponent of same-sex “marriage” says President Obama threw a bone to homosexual activists Wednesday, but they’re acting like “playground bullies” because he’s not moving quickly enough to enact their top priorities.









